Approach to costs
Solicitors at Humphreys & Co. always aim to approach
legal work in a financially-disciplined way. We offer
competitive rates. Our charging approach is both transparent
and geared to the options open to our clients. Our
solicitors generally charge by reference to time spent but
we can often agree fixed fees for specific work or in some
cases risk-adjusted funding structures.
|
Send us a summary of your circumstances and objectives for a quick response. |
|
 |
Building and construction - contract - damages
Construction contracts: variation: architects: contract price: JCT standard form: instructions; contract terms: meaning of variation instruction issued by architect: tendering process: arbitrators: contract formation: quantity surveyors: fees
No appeal lay against an arbitrator's finding that a variation instruction issued by the architect supervising a building project had contractual effect; furthermore, the arbitrator had been correct to find that the requirements of that instruction as to the agreeing of the contract price had been complied with.
Hallamshire Construction PLC -v- South Holland District Council (2004)
Technology and Construction Court (HH Judge Thornton QC) 16/1/2004
The appellant contractor (H) appealed against the arbitrator's findings that a variation instruction issued by a project architect (S) had contractual effect and that the requirements of the instruction as to the agreement of the contract price had been complied with. H had entered into a building contract with the local authority, which incorporated the 1980 local authorities with quantities JCT form of building contract. The parties agreed that phase 2 of the project, which concerned fitting-out works, would be dealt with by means of a variation instruction issued by S. The instruction provided, inter alia, that all terms and conditions would be in accordance with the existing contact and that "all costs in connection with this variation [were] to be agreed at fair and reasonable costs" by the quantity surveyors nominated under the contract. A dispute of H's fees arose, and the matter was referred to arbitration. The arbitrator found that S's instruction had contractual effect and that a revised scope of work and contract price for that work had been agreed by the parties, in part by a process of offer and acceptance, in part by negotiation and in part by conduct. H argued that (1) the effect of S's instruction had merely been to set up a tendering process whereby the parties would attempt to agree a concluded contract for the phase 2 works, with the result that the arbitrator had erred in finding that the instruction had contractual effect; (2) the process of agreement required by S's instruction was one involving the bills as a whole, with the result that the arbitrator had erred in finding, as he had, that the bills had been open to piecemeal negotiation and agreement.
HELD: (1) The arbitrator's finding that S's instruction had contractual effect did not raise a question of law and was therefore unappealable. (2) In the light of the wording of S's instruction, taken against the factual background, it was clear that the arbitrator had correctly interpreted the relevant words of the instruction. The process of agreement required of the quantity surveyors was one that involved the agreement of individual work items and their cost; it was not one that involved the negotiation and finalisation of an entire contract or a composite set of bills of quantities. It followed that there had been an agreement as to the cost of the works. No offer had been needed and the absence of an acceptance, using the concepts of "offer" and "acceptance" as they were used in the law relating to contract formation, was immaterial.
Appeal dismissed.
"Lawtel": 16.3.04
|
|
Accessibility
We take instructions from UK & international clients. Our independent lawyers are available by email, telephone & fax. With central Bristol offices we are just 90 minutes from London by road or rail and 15 minutes from Bristol International Airport. We can travel to meetings if required.
|
Independent approach
We are an independent professional law firm here, not a legal factory turning out mass-produced products. In our experience, determined case-handling is more likely to produce effective results.
|
Turnaround time
Solicitors at Humphreys & Co. look to input not only
careful legal work and precision but also the determination
to keep matters moving. They aim to work in clients' real
interests with energy and pragmatism.
|
Communication skills
Solicitors at Humphreys & Co. always try to open up the
legal process by giving advice and explaining options to
clients in a concise and straightforward way, identifying
clear courses of action whatever the technical or legal
complexities of the subject. |
|
